
On October 12, 2022, we followed the seminar Nicotine and Society: Ahead of the Tobacco Products Directive (TPD3), which was broadcast from the European Parliament in Brussels. The discussion focused on nicotine products, harm reduction, and a future review of the EU’s tobacco regulations.

What was discussed during the seminar?
The participants discussed how e-cigarettes, tobacco-free snus, and other nicotine products should be regulated. A central question was whether harm reduction should be given greater consideration in the EU’s regulatory work: reducing illness and deaths resulting from smoking through changes in consumption patterns.
Common EU rules and the possibilities for smokers to quit smoking or remain smoke-free were also included in the discussion. The seminar was presented by EPHI, Environment and Public Health Institute.
What did Jindřich Vobořil and Sara Skyttedal raise?
At the time, Jindřich Vobořil was the Czech Republic’s national drug coordinator. He advocated harm reduction and giving alternatives to smoking, including e-cigarettes and snus, a role in European regulation. His arguments concerned the possibility of preventing harm and deaths from smoking.
At the time, Sara Skyttedal was a Member of the European Parliament for the Christian Democrats and belonged to the EPP Group. She argued that public health efforts should focus on cancer and other diseases caused by tobacco use and highlighted changed nicotine consumption as a possible path to harm reduction.
Which health issues were addressed?
The debate addressed the difference between nicotine addiction and harm caused by combustible tobacco. Tobacco smoke contains harmful substances that form when tobacco burns. E-cigarettes instead heat a liquid into an aerosol that may contain nicotine and other harmful substances.
Nicotine and caffeine are stimulants with different risk profiles. Nicotine is addictive and can increase heart rate and blood pressure. E-cigarettes are not risk-free and are not approved or recommended as smoking cessation products in Sweden.
WHO’s 2021 report on the global tobacco epidemic described a declining global proportion of smokers.
What role did economic interests play?
The seminar also addressed investments and how the market for new nicotine products should be assessed. Changing consumption patterns could affect tobacco companies’ operations, while countries had different views on regulation. We saw economic interests as part of the political discussion.
What did the discussion mean for future regulations?
TPD3 was used in the seminar’s title for the expected review of the EU’s Tobacco Products Directive. The seminar was an opportunity for discussion and did not entail any decision on new regulations. The existing EU framework was the Tobacco Products Directive 2014/40/EU.
We were cautiously positive that harm reduction and alternatives to smoking were discussed. Our position was that the effects of regulations needed to be examined and taken into account before far-reaching bans were introduced. We wanted to see decisions based on research and continued to follow the issue of e-liquids and e-cigarettes.
Your friends at cigge.se
Quick Facts
- Reading Time
- 3 min
- Popularity
- Very Popular
- Category
- Rules & travel
- Published
- 2022-10-13