
In March 2023, we discussed a study on how the design, settings and flavoring of e-cigarettes affect emissions. The study was published in 2020 by researchers affiliated with, among others, Rutgers University and the Desert Research Institute in the USA.
What did the researchers investigate?
The researchers measured carbonyl compounds, including aldehydes, in machine-generated aerosol from e-cigarettes. They varied power, puffing patterns, liquid base and flavorings. Data on how 23 people took puffs were used in the experiments and exposure calculations. The study did not follow any cases of disease and did not test any smoking cessation method.
E-cigarettes heat e-liquid and produce aerosol without tobacco combustion. The amount of a substance in aerosol, how much a person takes in and the risk of developing disease are different questions.
How did the emissions differ from cigarette smoke?
For the bottom-positioned coils included in the comparison, the formaldehyde mass per puff was between one-tenth and one ten-thousandth of that in cigarette smoke. This corresponds to a factor of 10–10,000. The comparison included both the researchers’ own measurements and previously published results.
A separate model for daily exposure produced a different comparison measure. There, diacetyl exposure was estimated at approximately one hundred and twenty-fifth of that from cigarettes, or a factor of 125. In the model, formaldehyde exposure could simultaneously be approximately twice as high and glyoxal exposure approximately four times as high as with cigarette smoking. The calculations depended on the device and usage assumptions.
What did the coil’s position and the power mean?
In the researchers’ own experiments, a design with a bottom-positioned coil was used. Comparisons with older designs with a top-positioned coil were also based on previous studies. Both types used a wick to bring liquid to the heating element. A shorter wick and the liquid supply were important for heat management.
Higher power and longer puffs increased formaldehyde emissions in the combinations tested. However, not all substances followed the same pattern. Some top-positioned coils produced more formaldehyde per puff than cigarette smoke.
The study established no interval for coil replacement and did not compare all modern models. A coil needs to have an adequate liquid supply; stop using it when there is a burnt taste and replace a burnt coil.
What did the PG and VG tests show?
Propylene glycol, PG, produced more formaldehyde and acetaldehyde than vegetable glycerin, VG, under the conditions tested. VG could also produce degradation products; glyoxal occurred at higher power. The results describe emissions in the experiments and are not a general ranking of the liquids’ health risks.
In the discussion, the researchers referred to older literature on the degradation of PG at 127 °C and VG at 200 °C. These temperatures were not safe operating limits established in the e-cigarette experiments. Heating, liquid supply and the composition of the mixture affect which substances are formed.
Flavorings and product information
The flavor composition of e-liquid affected which carbonyl compounds were measured. Notification for sale does not mean that the product has received EU approval of its safety.
Diacetyl and popcorn lung
Diacetyl is a substance with a buttery flavor. Inhalation can damage the small airways and has, in occupational settings, been linked to bronchiolitis obliterans, commonly known as popcorn lung.
In the experiments, diacetyl was measured in aerosol from e-liquids with the flavorings Bavarian Cream, Sweet Cream and Graham Cracker. The levels were between 21.1 and 86.4 nanograms per puff. The study also discussed that acetoin, which can be used in butter flavorings, can oxidize to diacetyl during storage.
Diacetyl is also present in cigarette smoke. The study investigated neither how often popcorn lung occurs among smokers nor among people who use e-cigarettes. The comparison with an animal experiment did not provide a reliable limit for long-term human use. The authors called for more knowledge about chronic exposure to low diacetyl levels.
What does the study say about health and smoking cessation?
The study shows that design, use and liquid content affect emissions. It does not calculate a general reduction in the risk of cancer or lung disease and does not show that any e-cigarette is risk-free. The investigation included one device configuration and laboratory-prepared liquids; the analytical method could also underestimate certain carbonyl compounds.
Quitting smoking reduces the health risks of smoking. E-cigarettes carry their own health risks and are neither approved nor recommended as smoking cessation products in Sweden.
The original study
The Impact of Device Settings, Use Patterns, and Flavorings on Carbonyl Emissions from Electronic Cigarettes. Son, Weisel, Wackowski, Schwander, Delnevo and Meng, 2020. Published in International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health, 17(16), 5650. DOI: 10.3390/ijerph17165650.
Quick Facts
- Reading Time
- 4 min
- Popularity
- Very Popular
- Category
- Health & research
- Published
- 2023-03-08